A Bi-Generational Odyssey
As the sands of time shift for the iconic series 'Doctor Who', executive producer Russell T. Davies heralded a cosmic tide of change for its 60th-anniversary celebration. Promising a labyrinth of new twists in the show's rich tapestry, these special episodes were not just a nod to the past but a bold leap into the future, setting the stage for Ncuti Gatwa's groundbreaking entrance as the enigmatic Time Lord.
Amidst the interstellar drama, Davies' vision wove contemporary threads into the fabric of 'Doctor Who', reshaping the dynamics of the Doctor's allies and adversaries. These alterations, though rooted in modern sensibilities, were only the prelude to a more profound transformation.
Yet, the arrival of Gatwa's Doctor - a trailblazing figure marking it the first time the lead role has been portrayed by a Black, queer actor - it was a celestial event shadowed by complexities. This chronicle unveils the intricacies of all three episodes of this momentous special, revealing the highs and lows of 'Doctor Who's journey through time and space, where history is made and yet sometimes, the light of new stars struggles to shine through the legacy of the old.
[Spoilers: This exploration contains revelations from the entirety of the 60th-anniversary episodes, unfolding the secrets of time that may yet be unseen by many eyes.] In the cosmic dance of 'Doctor Who', the concept of regeneration stands as a mesmerizing enigma. It's the alchemical transformation allowing Time Lords (which is The Doctor species) to evolve into entirely new embodiments. This magical metamorphosis, more than a mere narrative device for the BBC to transition from one actor to another, is deeply woven into the lore of the series. As much as I don't want to admit but this, but in a way it can be seen as a cooler version of James Bond.
Each regeneration brings not just a fresh face but a very unique essence of The Doctor, memories of bygone eras intact yet distinct personalities emerging to forge new paths and form new alliances.
For six decades, this cycle of renewal and reinvention has been the pulsing heart of 'Doctor Who', a formula allowing it to traverse time with an ever-refreshing perspective.
In the show's resurgence post-2005, under the stewardship of show runners like Davies, Moffat, and Chibnall, these regenerations have transcended mere change. They have become grand finales and tantalizing overtures in one, a blend of farewell to the departing and a herald of the new. Yet, a curious twist in the tale emerged with the Thirteenth Doctor, portrayed by Jodie Whittaker, whose transformation marked a return to a familiar visage, echoing the Tenth Doctor, David Tennant.
This peculiar twist in the Doctor's regenerative saga, a narrative vortex that spins between the familiar and the unknown, reaches its zenith in "The Giggle." This climactic episode, the final chapter of the 60th-anniversary celebration, delves deep into the mysteries brewing within the Doctor. It's a journey into the heart of what makes the Doctor who they are, unraveling the enigma of a Time Lord caught in an unprecedented loop of there identity and existence.
Doctor Who's foray into representing transgender characters has sparked a spectrum of reactions among its viewers. Some fans, particularly those not identifying as LGBTQ, voiced discomfort with the inclusion of a transgender character, feeling it deviated from the show's essence. They feared that Russell T. Davies, the showrunner, might be misrepresenting the essence of Doctor Who, turning it into something unrecognizable.
Conversely, members of the LGBTQ community have raised concerns about certain portrayals in the series. Specifically, the mention of Rose's deadname in "The Star Beast" episode stirred debate. This narrative choice was seen by some as a conflation of the experiences of binary and non-binary transgender individuals, potentially muddying the waters for a predominantly cisgender audience.
From my perspective, however, the inclusion of deadnaming in the storyline serves a potent purpose. It starkly illustrates that only bullies and transphobes would knowingly use a trans person's deadname. The reality of deadnames is a nuanced aspect of many trans individuals' lives; each person navigates this aspect of their identity differently. In documentary or non-fictional settings, the use of deadnames should be avoided to respect the privacy and dignity of real individuals.
However, Rose Noble is a fictional character. She lacks real-world sensibilities, emotions, or a need for privacy. Hence, incorporating her deadname in a context that explicitly condemns the act of deadnaming doesn't harm her - because she's a construct of fiction. Utilizing a fictional character to communicate this message can be highly effective. It educates viewers on the pain and harm deadnaming can inflict on real-life transgender individuals, like myself and Yasmin Finney. It's a bold and innovative approach to raising awareness and empathy, leveraging the power of storytelling to highlight an important issue within the LGBTQ more specifically the transgender/ transsexual community.
Following a poignant resolution with Donna Noble (Catherine Tate) in “The Star Beast”, and a perilous odyssey to the cosmos' fringes in “Wild Blue Yonder”, the Doctor finds himself back on Earth for a climactic showdown in “The Giggle”. Here, he faces a modern incarnation of the iconic series villain, The Toymaker, now reimagined through the talents of Neil Patrick Harris.
The Toymaker, brought to life first by Michael Gough, emerged as a physics-defying, game-obsessed entity with a penchant for creating lethal 'toys', making him a formidable adversary. In this new iteration, “The Giggle” reintroduces the character for the first time since his original appearance, now with a diabolical scheme to unleash global chaos through a hidden, rage-inducing signal embedded in every screen worldwide.
Russell T. Davies, in anticipation of this episode, spoke openly about his intentions with Harris’ portrayal of The Toymaker. He aimed to reflect upon the character's initial context and address the past portrayal of The Toymaker as an Asian-coded character by a white actor. This time, The Toymaker is depicted as a disconcerting German man, struggling to maintain his varying accents. This choice underscores The Toymaker's shape-shifting essence and serves as a symbolic parallel to the Doctor's current turmoil. The Doctor, disturbed by the mysteries surrounding his own regeneration process, finds in The Toymaker a reflection of his unsettled identity.
"The Giggle" elevates the tension with The Toymaker's nefarious plot to dominate the world and his dramatic attempt to eliminate the Fourteenth Doctor (David Tennant) in front of companions Donna Noble (Catherine Tate) and Mel Bush (Bonnie Langford). Yet, in an unexpected twist, instead of succumbing to a lethal laser strike, the Doctor emerges with only a strange sensation. This leads to a miraculous event when, upon Donna and Mel's intervention, his body astonishingly splits into two entities.
This phenomenon introduces the Fifteenth Doctor (Ncuti Gatwa), challenging the long-held Gallifreyan myth of 'bi-generation' - a Time Lord's ability to regenerate into two separate beings. As Fourteen and Fifteen join forces against The Toymaker, it becomes clear that this new era of Doctor Who will feature multiple concurrent Doctors. While this development excites fans who revere Tennant's portrayal, it also somewhat overshadows Gatwa's debut.
The announcement of Gatwa as the next Doctor, succeeding Jodie Whittaker's groundbreaking tenure, signaled the BBC's commitment to exploring the core themes of imagination and diversity inherent in Doctor Who. The series, having predominantly featured white male actors until 2017, began to address its past limitations, embracing a more inclusive representation reflective of its diverse fanbase. The introductions of Whittaker's Thirteen and Jo Martin's Fugitive Doctor paved the way for a more reflective portrayal of the Doctor, aligning with the real-world diversity of its audience.
However, the manner of Gatwa's introduction in "The Giggle" - notably his disproportionate exposure compared to Tennant's Fourteen and the suggestion of the two Doctors coexisting - raises questions about the show's direction. It appears to be a strategic move to appease a segment of the fanbase resistant to a queer, Black actor in the iconic role, reminiscent of past controversies surrounding casting choices in other franchises.
These reactionary fan responses have been observed in various contexts, from the introduction of Black characters in iconic roles across different media franchises to the mixed reception of diverse characters in popular series. Such attitudes highlight an ongoing challenge within genre fandoms. While "The Giggle" addresses the perils of such narrow-minded fervor, the concept of 'bi-generation' seems to cater to less progressive elements within the Doctor Who fan community.
The Giggle” thus not only presents a thrilling confrontation but also delves into a deep exploration of legacy and identity, both for the Doctor and one of his most enigmatic foes.
The 60th-anniversary specials have adeptly delved into the Doctor's layered relationships with human companions, revealing a sense of loss and regret. Further stories focusing on Fourteen and his companions might offer a deeper exploration of this facet of the Doctor's psyche. Tennant's previous success as the Doctor was partly due to the room he had to define the character, distinct from his predecessor.
However, "The Giggle" seems to place Gatwa at a potential disadvantage by positioning his era alongside Tennant's continuing presence. While it doesn't entirely limit Gatwa's opportunity to shape his version of the Doctor, it introduces an element of competition not faced by previous incarnations.
The upcoming Christmas special will undoubtedly shed more light on how 'Doctor Who' will navigate the implications of bi-generation and define Fifteen's role. Yet, with Fourteen's ongoing adventures, there's an underlying concern that Fifteen might have to vie for the spotlight in a manner unprecedented in the show's history. The hope remains that this won't diminish the unique presence and impact of Gatwa's Doctor.
The anticipation builds as fans await the next Doctor Who Christmas special, set to premiere on Christmas Day, heralding a new chapter in this timeless saga.
Read More
All Blogs
